• Home
  • Tax Law and Commentary Online
  • TCA1997 | Section 289 Calculation of balancing allowances and balancing charges in certain cases
Change year: 2010

Section 289 Calculation of balancing allowances and balancing charges in certain cases

Print_icon
Contents Previous section Next section |
Unlock_icon
Sign up to access full section commentary and legislation back years
subscription or 30 day access with no obligation

(1) In this section, "open-market price", in relation to any machinery or plant, means the price which the machinery or plant would have fetched if sold in the open market at the time of the event in question.

How is plant or machinery valued if a balancing adjustment has to be calculated without a disposal being made?

(1) Open market price rules are imposed where machinery or plant is not sold, but must be valued for the balancing adjustment. This may occur, for example, where your trade has permanently ceased, and plant remain unsold, or where machinery or plant ...

to read the full commentary

(2) Where-

(a) an event occurs which gives rise or might give rise to a balancing allowance or balancing charge in respect of machinery or plant,

(b) the event is the permanent discontinuance of a trade, and

(c) at or about the time of the discontinuance there occurs in relation to the machinery or plant any event mentioned in paragraphs (a) to (c) of section 318, not being a sale at less than open-market price other than a sale to which section 312 applies,

then, for the purpose of determining-

(i) whether the discontinuance gives rise to a balancing allowance or balancing charge, and, if so,

(ii) the amount of the allowance or, as the case may be, the amount on which the charge is to be made,

the amount of the net proceeds, compensation, receipts or insurance moneys mentioned in paragraphs (a) to (c) of section 318 which arise on the last-mentioned event shall be deemed to be an amount of sale, insurance, salvage or compensation moneys arising on the permanent discontinuance of the trade.

How is the balancing adjustment paid if my trade has ceased?

(2) Where your trade has permanently ceased, and you sell machinery or plant at or above open market price, the net sale proceeds are taken for the balancing adjustment. Similarly, if the machinery or plant is lost or destroyed, the net insurance or ...

to read the full commentary

(3)(a) Subject to subsections (4) and (6), paragraph (b) shall apply where an event occurs which gives rise or might give rise to a balancing allowance or balancing charge in respect of machinery or plant, and-

(i) the event is the permanent discontinuance of the trade and immediately after the time of the discontinuance the machinery or plant continues to belong to the person by whom the trade was carried on immediately before that time and the case is not one within subsection (2),

(ii) the event is the permanent discontinuance of the trade and at the time of the discontinuance the machinery or plant is either sold at less than the open-market price, the sale not being one to which section 312 applies, or the machinery or plant is given away,

(iii) the event is the sale of the machinery or plant at less than the open-market price, not being a sale to which section 312 applies, or is the gift of the machinery or plant, or

(iv) the event is that, after the setting up and before the permanent discontinuance of the trade, the machinery or plant permanently ceases to be used for the purposes of a trade carried on by the person by whom the first-mentioned trade is being carried on, and so ceases either by reason of that person's transferring the machinery or plant to other use or, on a transfer of the trade which is not treated as involving a discontinuance of the trade, by reason of the retention of the machinery or plant by the transferor.

(b) For the purpose of determining whether a balancing allowance or balancing charge is to be made and, if so, the amount of the allowance or, as the case may be, the amount on which the charge is to be made, the event shall be treated as if it had given rise to sale, insurance, salvage or compensation moneys of an amount equal to the open-market price of the machinery or plant.

How is my balancing adjustment calculated where there is a transfer of a lease at the end of the period of lease?

(3) If, after your trade has ceased, machinery or plant continues to belong to you, then the open market price at the date of cessation is taken as being the sale proceeds for the balancing adjustment. Similarly, if machinery or plant is given away (...

to read the full commentary

(4) References in subsection (3) to the sale of machinery or plant at less than the open-market price do not include references to the sale of machinery or plant in such circumstances that there is a charge to income tax under Schedule E by virtue of Chapter 3 of Part 5, and subsection (3)(b) shall not apply by reason of the gift of machinery or plant if the machinery or plant is given away in any such circumstances.

How do I calculate a balancing adjustment where I give away machinery or plant and the recipient is subject to BIK on receipt of the asset?

(4) Where you give away or sell machinery at less than open market price, and the purchaser or recipient is liable to an income tax benefit in kind charge on the receipt of the asset, only the net sale proceeds (if any) are taken into account in comp...

to read the full commentary

(5) Subject to subsection (6), where subsection (3)(b) applies by reason of the gift or sale of machinery or plant to any person, and that person receives or purchases the machinery or plant with a view to using it for the purposes of a trade carried on by that person, then, in determining whether any, and if so what, wear and tear allowances, balancing allowances or balancing charges are to be made in connection with that trade, the like consequences shall ensue as if the recipient or purchaser had purchased the machinery or plant at the open-market price.

Regarding wear and tear, what if I buy machinery for less than the market value?

(5) Where a person gives you or sells machinery to you at less than open market price, and you have bought the machinery for your trade, you are to be treated, for the purposes of wear and tear allowances and any future balancing adjustments, as if y...

to read the full commentary

(6) [Subject to subsection (6A), where in a case within subsection (5)]1 the recipient or purchaser and the donor or seller, by notice in writing to the inspector, jointly so elect, the following provisions shall apply:

(a) subsections (3)(b) and (5) shall apply as if for the references in those subsections to the open-market price there were substituted references to that price or the amount of the expenditure on the provision of the machinery or plant still unallowed immediately before the gift or sale, whichever is the lower;

(b) notwithstanding anything in this Chapter, such balancing charge, if any, shall be made on the recipient or purchaser on any event occurring after the date of the gift or sale as would have been made on the donor or seller if the donor or seller had continued to own the machinery or plant and had done all such things and been allowed all such allowances in connection with the machinery or plant as were done by or allowed to the recipient or purchaser.

Amendments

1 Substituted by Finance Act 2003 section 47(1)(a) as respects a gift or sale of machinery or plant on or after 6 February 2003.

As the seller of machinery, can I avoid a balancing charge on the disposal of machinery?

(6) You may jointly agree with the new owners to treat the transfer as if the machinery had been sold to the new owner at a price equal to the amount of the unallowed expenditure just before the gift or sale or, if lower, at the open market value. In...

to read the full commentary

(6A)(a) Subsection (6) shall only apply in a case where the donor or seller is connected with the recipient or purchaser.

(b) Notwithstanding paragraph (a), subsection (6) shall not apply in any case where the donor or seller is not a company and the recipient or purchaser is a company.

Amendments

Subs (6A) inserted by Finance Act 2003 section 47(1)(b) as respects a gift or sale of machinery or plant on or after 6 February 2003.

Is there any restriction on the provision which allows the previous owner to avoid a balancing charge on the sale of machinery?

(6A) This is an anti-avoidance provision. From 6 February 2003, the election in (6), which allows you as the old owner to postpone a balancing charge where machinery or plant is gifted or sold at undervalue, only applies where the you are connected w...

to read the full commentary
Print_icon
Contents Previous section Next section